Knowsley Council recently hosted an Ad Hoc Joint Health Scrutiny Committee, convened by eight of the nine councils in Cheshire and Merseyside to carry out further scrutiny of proposed changes to NHS-funded fertility treatment policies across the area.
Citing significant financial pressures, and the need to harmonise fertility treatment policies across the Cheshire and Merseyside area, the NHS are proposing to reduce the number funded IVF cycles from the current position which ranges from three to two, down to one funded cycle. This is anticipated to save NHS Cheshire and Merseyside approximately £1.3m per year.
At its meeting, the Joint Committee, Chaired by Cllr Gary Bennett from Knowsley Council, has formally expressed serious concerns regarding the proposed changes. In a letter to the Integrated Care Board (ICB), the Committee will highlight reservations about reducing the number of funded IVF cycles to just one.
Key issues raised at the joint committee include:
- Clinical justification: The Committee questioned the evidence behind the reduction and its alignment with NICE guidance.
- Treatment effectiveness: Members noted that success rates improve with multiple cycles and warned that limiting access may compromise outcomes.
- Equity concerns: The financial burden on patients for additional cycles could disproportionately affect lower-income groups.
- Public opposition: 86% of consultation respondents opposed the changes, including advocacy groups and NHS staff.
- Unassessed impacts: The Committee called for further evaluation of potential effects on mental health, birth rates, and increased demand on other NHS services.
The Committee has requested a follow-up meeting with ICB officers to discuss these concerns and explore possible mitigations. It remains committed to supporting equitable and evidence-based fertility services for local communities.
